- Morning Huddle
- Posts
- π Who should be the first pick?
π Who should be the first pick?
CMC vs JT. Plus more Dameon Peirce, Trey Lance, and Rashaad Penny.
Good morning. If youβre at all into comedy, watch Sam Darnold practice against the Panthers first team defense.
Sam Darnold with the ones. And he is promptly picked off by Jalen Mills on the first play of team.
β Joe Person (@josephperson)
3:36 PM β’ Aug 17, 2022
I should note, Baker Mayfield is expected to be named the Panthers starting QB for Week 1. Now please checkout this perfect breakdown of Kenny Golladay's contract by Stephie Smalls.
By the end of this newsletter, you'll be convinced that CMC is the #1 overall pick, Trey Lance is clutch, Dameon Peirce should be on your roster, and the drive-thru attendant spit in my food.
The Hype
Risers: Trending Up
Rashaad Penny // Seahawks.com
From 49ers camp: "Trey Lance completed 11 of 16 passes today against the Vikings. His best play was a 30-yard completion to Deebo Samuel on 4th and 10 with the game on the line. Lance scrambled to his right and threw back across his body. Lance is a clutch playmaker."
The Athletic's Daniel Popper reported that RB Joshua Kelley appears to be "firmly in the lead" to backup Austin Ekeler. Kelley is often undrafted (or drafted behind rookie RB Isaiah Spiller). That should change. Be the change.
"Thereβs a world in which Jahan Dotson out-targets Terry McLaurin this season" - Seemingly hot take from @AdamKoffler might not be so bold. Wentz & team love Dotson, as does our own Coach Wehler. Absolute steal at his ADP (140+).
Some interesting points on why you should draft Isaiah McKenzie:
Isaiah McKenzie (ADP: WR69)
- 27.0 FPG in the 2 games he's earned 6+ targets since 2019
- Rested preseason W1 (appears to have starting slot locked up)
- Cole Beasley finished no worse than WR48 in 3 seasons with BUF
- Beasley had 112 targets last yearβ Jake Tribbey (@JakeTribbey)
5:56 PM β’ Aug 17, 2022
Morning Huddle favorite and end-of-2021 season winner Rashaad Penny is back in the drivers seat as Seattle's RB1 after Kenneth's surgery. "I feel amazing, and this is the best Iβve ever felt,β Penny told reporters.
Meanwhile, Seahawks RB Kenneth Walker will undergo a "procedure" for his mysterious (hernia?) injury and will miss the remainder of the preseason. Pete Carroll is optimistic Walker will be back shortly after preseason.
Brian Drake: Remember last year when Carroll said Chris Carson was fine? Dude legit retired. Never trust Pete, ever. Penny is the play here.
As always, more Dameon Pierce hype:
Inject this Dameon Pierce pass pro rep into all of my veins oh my God
β Brett Kollmann (@BrettKollmann)
7:57 PM β’ Aug 17, 2022
The Big Story
The Great Debate: CMC vs JT
Cry me a river, Justin. I'm taking CMC.
I consume Fantasy Points' Jake Tribbey's content like Zeke eats cereal. And yesterday, Jake wrote THE thread on why Christian McCaffrey > Jonathan Taylor. Of course, you have to read the entire thread. But the most convincing points Jake raises:
1. Jonathan Taylor is gamescript dependent. Taylor is 1975 OJ Simpson (27.4 FPG) in wins, but a mid-range RB1 in losses (18.0 FPG). Plus, the Colts mentioned reducing Taylor's workload multiple times this season.
2. McCaffrey has an all-time great receiving role (averaged 8.1 targets per game since 2018, more than Tee Higgins, Terry McLaurin, Michael Pittman saw last year).
3. CMC is better in losses. Since 2018, CMC in wins: 23.9 FPG. CMC in losses: 26.7 FPG. Panthers implied to lose around 10 games.
4. In McCaffrey's last 21 healthy games, he's finished as a top 8 RB 95% of the time. Keep in mind that in Taylor's last 21 games, he's finished as a top-6 RB just 43% of the time - half as much as McCaffrey.
5. "Taylor has great upside, but CMC has all-time great upside - to the point it could be nearly impossible to win your league without him." Draft CMC and thank us later. And thank Jake now.
If you need more convincing:
"But, the Panthers will reduce his workload!"
CMC is making the highest annual salary ($16,000,000) of any RB in football. The Panthers have a MASSIVE financial incentive to play him.
Just look at how much Zeke Elliott has played despite being the 2nd-best RB on his own team
β Jake Tribbey (@JakeTribbey)
5:17 PM β’ Aug 17, 2022
Four Quotes
Melvin gets your hopes up
Melvin Gordon // Chargers.com
"They want Javonte [Williams] to be the guy." - Melvin Gordon made it clear that Javonte is the 1A in the Broncos backfield, when asked about the team's plans at RB. He could also have been talking about us. #FreeJavonte.
"Bag secured." - (Probably) the agent of Chargers S Derwin James, after James secured the biggest payday for a safety in NFL history with a four-year, $76.4 million extension through 2026.
"I was describing it to my wife: I feel like it's Pokemon and you're just sending out your next Pokemon." - Jets RB coach on managing the RB rotation. Of course, Breece Hall is Charmander.
"At this point, I'm not sure if the 6th is too high for Dameon Peirce" - Me, to a drive-through attendant that didn't deserve it.
Overtime
Quick Slants
Put this in the dictionary under: Mildly Amusing
Colts sixth-round TE Andrew Ogletree suffered a torn ACL in Wednesday's practice and will miss the season. Ogletree was balling at camp, so this injury opens things up for Massive Mo Alie-Cox.
Darren Waller (hamstring) returned to practice Wednesday. Fantasy owners, such as yours truly, can finally relax.
Mecole Hardman suffered a groin injury in Chiefs practice Wednesday and the "initial thought" is that the injury is not serious, but more tests will be conducted soon.
Pro Football Network's Aaron Wilson reported that the NFLPA is engaged in "active settlement negotiations" with the NFL in the Deshaun Watson case. It is unclear how interested the league is in a settlement, but "sources expressed optimism that a deal will get worked out." A settlement improves Watson's odds of playing this season.
Tweet of the Day
HES BEHIND MARLON MACK ON THE DEPTH CHART BUT IF YOU WATCHED PRESEASON WEEK ONE YOU KNOW DAMEON PIERCE IS GONNA BE RB1 IN NO TIME AT ALL
β Mina Kimes (@minakimes)
10:36 PM β’ Aug 17, 2022
Thanks for joining us this morning - it was a quick one, giving you plenty of time to make those trade offers you'll regret later this season.
- Jake, Eddie, Matt & Coach Wehler.
Reply